GOOD HOUSEKEEPING PARENTING AWARD WINNER!

SwingSesh vs. Vuly Play: The Premium Choice is Clear

Adding a playset to your backyard is a sure way to provide years of fun for your family. As this is a purchase you'll likely make only once, it’s important to choose a set that offers features your kids will enjoy for years, durability that will stand the test of time, and a price that fits your budget. With so many options available, the decision can feel overwhelming. But don’t worry – we’re here to help! In this comprehensive guide, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know to choose the perfect metal playset for your family’s needs.


Key Factors to Help You Choose the Best Metal Playset

Before diving into brand comparisons, it's essential to understand the key factors that will guide you in choosing the best metal playset for your family. The most important features to consider are durability, safety features, ease of assembly, design, features, and expected use lifetime. Let's go into more detail on each of those so you know what to look for as you're shopping:

Durability

Durability is one of the most critical factors when selecting a playset. Since a backyard playset is a long-term investment, you’ll want something that can withstand the elements and heavy usage for years. Durability depends on the materials used and the overall build quality.

  • Metal Type: The type and thickness of the metal used in the frame—whether it’s steel, galvanized steel, or stainless steel—directly impact the playset's strength and longevity. Stainless steel is generally more resistant to rust and corrosion, but it might come with a higher price tag. Galvanized steel is a common choice for durability at a more affordable cost.
  • Coating and Finish: A good coating is essential to protect the playset from weather damage. Look for finishes that offer thermal protection, such as powder coating or enamel, which will help resist rust and corrosion over time. The thickness of the coating is also important; thicker coatings provide better protection against wear and tear, keeping the playset looking great and performing well for years.
  • Construction Style: Many metal playset manufacturers use a snap together tube design, which is easy to install. When it comes to strength and durability, welded steel construction is far superior. Welded designs have bolted connections that provide strong connections as well as easy disassembly and reassembly without risk of damaging structural parts.
  • Manufacturer’s Maintenance Recommendations: Every metal playset comes with a set of manufacturer’s maintenance guidelines. Adhering to these recommendations, such as cleaning schedules or periodic inspections, can significantly extend the playset's life.

Safety Features

Safety should always be your top priority when purchasing a playset. Accidents can happen, but choosing a playset with strong safety features will minimize the risks.

  • Rounded Edges and Smooth Surfaces: Ensure the playset has rounded or smooth edges to reduce the risk of cuts and bruises. The design should also include secure and sturdy construction to minimize any wobbling or instability.
  • Age Recommendations: Pay attention to the recommended age range for the playset. Some playsets are designed specifically for toddlers, while others are suitable for older kids. A playset that fits the developmental stage of your children will ensure they have a safe and enjoyable experience.
  • Weight Limits: Always check the maximum recommended weight capacity for swings, slides, and climbing walls. Overloading the playset can result in wear and tear or even cause structural issues, compromising safety.

Ease of Assembly

An easy-to-assemble playset is key to reducing frustration. Opting for a playset with straightforward assembly can save you time and effort.

  • Clear Assembly Instructions: Look for brands that offer clear, step-by-step instructions with visual guides. This will make the assembly process easier and ensure the playset is built correctly.
  • Check Reviews: Take the time to read reviews from other buyers to gauge how easy (or difficult) the assembly process is. Often, customer feedback will give you a better sense of what to expect.
  • Anchoring System: Is the anchoring system adequate for your environment and soil type?  Some manufacturers sell the anchors separately, so be sure to find out if those are included or if that’s an additional cost to consider.
  • Professional Installation: If you’re not the DIY type, you may want to have the playset professionally installed. Check to see if the manufacturer offers installation services or if you’ll need to coordinate that on your own. Assembly service pricing varies widely depending on your region and many playset assembly companies get booked months in advance for spring installations and installations prior to the holidays.

Design and Features

Modular Metal Playset

Metal playsets come in a wide variety of designs and features. Some may be more suitable for smaller yards, while others offer more options for customization and expansion.

  • Variety of Features: Features such as swings, slides, and monkey bars are common on metal swing sets, but some also offer additional features like climbing ropes, climbing walls, or even fitness equipment. Consider what your family will enjoy most and ensure that the features fit your space and needs.
  • Modularity and Customization: Most playsets have one out-of-the-box configuration, but a few metal playsets allow you to add or remove features as needed. If you want the flexibility to modify or expand your playset in the future, look for a modular design that allows for upgrades.
  • Customization: Most metal playset manufacturers only offer one, or maybe two set color schemes. The higher end manufacturers offer a variety of color schemes and even custom colors to perfectly match your backyard design.

Expected Use Lifetime

Strongest Metal Playset

It's easy to overlook, but the lifespan of a playset extends beyond just how long it will last physically—will it still be fun for your family as your children grow? Many playsets are designed primarily for younger kids, typically up to around 12 years old, and may not offer features that appeal to older kids or adults. You’re not investing in a backyard play set to have the kids outgrow it in a few years!

  • Universal Features: Consider investing in a playset that can handle the weight of older kids and adults. Features such as taller swings, climbing structures, and stronger materials can ensure that the playset remains enjoyable as your children grow. As kids get into sports, having a set strong enough to support pull-ups and other bodyweight exercises is an excellent way to keep it relevant.
  • Long-Term Enjoyment: A well-designed metal playset should provide entertainment for multiple age groups. Features like multiple swings, slides, and areas for climbing or even working out can keep your kids engaged for years to come, making it a worthwhile long-term investment.

By keeping these factors in mind as you shop around, you’ll be better equipped to choose a metal playset that not only meets your immediate needs but also provides lasting enjoyment for years to come.


Let's take a look at some metal playset options in depth to compare some of these critical factors.

SwingSesh with Monkey Bars

SwingSesh Fitness Playset with Monkey Bars

Vuly Family Quest Pro w/ Hideout Monkey Bars

 

Features

✔ 2 swings (modular to 4)
✔ Monkey Bars
✔ Slide
✔ Play Deck
✔ Climbing Wall
Pull-up Bars
Dip Bars
Squat Rack
Box Jumps
Ab Station
15-ft Rope Climb (optional)
Landmine, Wall Ball Target, Battle Rope Attachments (optional)

Swings optional
Monkey Bars
Slide
Fabric ‘Hideout’ Deck
Climbing Features
Pull-up Bars
Dip Bars
Squat Rack
Box Jumps
Ab Station


Metal  Heavy-gauge steel 2 ½ in square tube Thin-gauge galvanized steel pipe
Overall Weight Limit (Static Load) 5,000 lbs 1650 lbs
Deck Weight Limit 2,000 lbs Not specified
Swing Weight Limit 250 lbs per swing Not specified
Swing Bar Height 8-ft (9-ft option available) 7.18-ft
Slide 10-ft long thick rotomolded double-walled slide, one solid piece None available
Coating

Premium ~200-micron thick thermoplastic coating

3x thicker coating provides better protection with a soft, rubbery feel that is cooler to the touch in extreme temps and can be repaired at home

Galvanization & stainless steel options available to provide additional protection for harsh or coastal environments

Standard ~60-micron thermoset coating

Thinner brittle coating can crack, fade, and original coating cannot be repaired in the field


Anchors

Aluminum screw-style earth penetrators drive 18-inches into the ground

Earth Anchors


Swing Seats

Rigid seats that are more comfortable for adults

Coated chain for durability & comfort

Rigid swing seat

Rigid seat

Rope instead of chain

Swing Hardware Stainless steel pendulums, snap hooks, & bolts
Origin

Made in USA

Made in America

Imported from China

Made in China

Customizable Modular and customizable design grows with your family Limited modularity

 

 

SwingSesh with Monkey Bars

Vuly Family Quest Pro w/ Hideout Monkey Bars

Features

2 swings (modular to 4)
Monkey Bars
Slide
Play Deck
Climbing Features
Pull-up Bars
Dip Bars
Squat Rack
Box Jumps
Ab Station
15-ft Rope Climb
Landmine, Wall Ball Target, Battle Rope Attachments (optional)

Swings
Monkey Bars
Slide
Fabric ‘Hideout’ Deck
Climbing Features
Pull-up Bars
Dip Bars
Squat Rack
Box Jumps
Ab Station

Climbing Rope

Fitness Attachments

 

 

Metal 

Heavy-gauge steel 2 ½ in square tube

Thin-gauge galvanized steel pipe

Overall Weight Limit (Static Load)

5,000 lbs

1,650 lbs

Deck Weight Limit

2,000 lbs

Not specified

Swing Weight Limit

250 lbs per swing

Not specified

Swing Bar Height

8-ft (9-ft option available)

7.18-ft

Slide

10-ft long thick rotomolded double-walled slide

None available

Coating

Premium ~200 micron thermoplastic coating

3x thicker coating provides better protection with a soft, rubbery feel that is cooler to the touch in extreme temps and can be repaired at home

Galvanization available to provide additional protection for harsh or coastal environments

Standard ~60 microns thermoset coating

Thinner brittle coating can crack, fade, and cannot be repaired in the field

Colors

Available in Gray, Blue, Green, Red, and Custom Colors available

Black & Orange

Anchors

Aluminum screw-style earth penetrators drive 18-inches into the ground

Earth Anchors

Includes stakes

Recommended Age Range

5yo – 99yo

6yo – max weight 120kg (264lb)

Users

Not specified

Max 2 users at a time

Swing Seats

Rigid seats that are more comfortable for adults

Coated chain for durability & comfort


Several options, included a rigid seat

Rope instead of chain

Origin

Made in USA

Made in America

Imported from China

Made in China

Customizable

Modular and customizable design grows with your family

Limited modularity